June 11, 2010
The Cost of Stroke Treatment (Study)
A recent Canadian study found that the average financial cost of a stroke during the first 6 months is approximately $50,000. The study found that health-care covered around 80% of the costs, leaving the families to cover the additional 20%.
Most of the health-care costs related to hospitalization, whereas the remaining 20% related to lost time from jobs and expenses for the families.
Every year, 50,000 Canadians suffer a stroke and require treatment, which works out to an cost of more than $2.5 Billion each year.
The study examined 12 hospitals across the country, from Halifax to Vancouver, and tracked 232 patients during their stay in the hospital and after they returned home. Tracked costs included:
- appointments
- medications
- purchase of assistive devices like canes or wheelchairs
- home accessibility modifications such as ramps
- caregiver time away from a job
You can read more about the study here.
March 18, 2010
Robot Stroke Rehabilitation Results in “Modest Improvements”
A recent randomized trial of 127 stroke survivors has shown no significant difference between rehabilitation with the assistance of a robotic workstation and more conventional rehabilitation with the assistance of a human.
The study, conducted by Dr. Albert Lo of the Providence VA Medical Center in Rhode Island, separated 127 participants into three groups: human-assisted rehabilitation (50 patients), robot-assisted rehabilitation (49 patients), and usual care consisting of treatment with antiplatelets, antihypertensives and recommendations for diet and exercise (28 patients).
Dr. Lo described improvements in both the robot-assisted and human-assisted as “fairly modest.” He went on to say that the improvements were important “because there’s very little available for people with chronic stroke.”
The study focused on rehabilitation of the upper extremity, involving repetitive rehabilitation exercises in stroke patients with moderate-to-severe arm disability. The rehabilitation programs lasted 12 weeks, three one-hour sessions per week, and involved the same number of repetitions of arm exercises.
Outcome evaluations were performed immediately after the 12 week rehabilitation program, and included the Fugl-Meyer Assessment of basic motor function (the primary endpoint), the Wolf Motor Function Test of time to complete everyday tasks, and the Stroke Impact Scale. No significant differences were found between the human-assisted and robot-assisted treatment groups.
At the end of the follow-up period (36 weeks), patients who received robot or human-assisted rehabilitation had slightly better scores on all outcome measures than those in the usual care.
There were no differences between robot-assisted and human-assisted rehab on any of the outcomes at any time point.
The cost difference in treatment was substantial: the initial cost of the robots was $200,000, and the cost of the robot-assisted rehab program was around $1200 more per patient than that of usual care over the course of the year.
From this article, I gather that the robots were made by Interactive Motion Technologies.
October 14, 2009
Constraint Induced Therapy at Home
What is Constraint Induced Therapy (CIT)?
Initially called “forced use therapy,” constraint induced (movement) therapy (CIT) is the principle of immobilizing one hand so that the participant uses only the other hand during therapy. During hand rehabilitation in stroke, for example, participants wear a mitten on their less affected hand and perform exercise tasks with only their weak hand.
For many years researchers had known that intensive exercise therapy (IET) accelerated recovery in the central nervous system. The related term “neuroplasticity” was introduced to describe the ability of the nervous system to reorganize itself after injury.
In a 2006 randomized controlled trial, stroke rehabilitation researchers found that CIT resulted in larger improvements than conventional therapy. So, it appears that CIT can be an important component of a successful recovery after a neurological injury such as stroke or spinal cord injury.
Here’s a video of Constraint Induced Movement Therapy:
What are the limitations of CIT?
In most cases, CIT providers require subjects to have a minimum level of functional movement in their affected limb. This excludes many people with moderate levels of disability. Perhaps the major limitation of CIT in its original form is the requirement that participants spend up to 3 weeks in a clinic. This can be prohibitively expensive, sometimes costing more than $20,000 for therapy, accommodation, and travel.
Only a few rehabilitation clinics offer the “authorized” version of CIT, so you may need to relocate for a period of time to participate. In most cases, this is very expensive, so it is worth contacting your insurance company before you embark on this option. Less intensive protocols have been suggested, e.g. modified CIT (mCIT) in which a therapist supervises CIT for 30 minutes/day, 3 times/week for 10 weeks and in addition the participant performs self-directed exercise tasks 5 hours/day, 5 days/week with a mitt on the less affected hand. The supervised portions can occur at home if the therapist uses a telerehabilitation link.
Finally, you can conduct a program on your own. You will set up a regimen of training exercises for yourself and wear a mitt on your less affected hand. Do a Google search for mCIT (or Modified Constraint Induced Therapy) before beginning so that you understand what’s involved. Be sure to ask your doctor or physical or occupational therapist whether they recommend self-directed mCIT BEFORE you begin
New ways of delivering Intensive Exercise Therapy (IET)
The latest approach to upper extremity rehabilitation is to use devices that provide task-specific IET of the shoulder, arm and hand. The tasks include “range-of-motion” of the shoulder and arm as well as grasp and release tasks of the hand. The latest devices, like the ReJoyce system for example, use computers to track these movements and control highly-motivating computer games.
Telerehabilitation providers are beginning to emerge online. In this case, a provider will run through an assessment with you online. Provided you fit their criteria and have physician approval, they will ship you the necessary equipment. Your caregiver will set up the equipment and the provider will schedule rehabilitation sessions with you. During these sessions, a therapist will supervise you directly using a web cam. Often, the therapist can configure the equipment in your home to match your exercise requirements. You will likely need to have your caregiver present for these sessions for safety reasons. Telerehabilitation is usually much less expensive than in-clinic rehabilitation.
June 15, 2009
Rick Hansen Wheels in Motion
Rick Hansen Wheels in Motion, a Canadian fund raising organization, recently provided funding for Jennifer Gabrysh to participate in a telerehabilitation trial involving ReJoyce trial at the University of Alberta. Here’s an excerpt from the article:
“- Regina native Jennifer Gabrysh was able to participate in a research study being conducted at the University of Alberta to validate a technology that will allow tetraplegics to maximize their hand function.”
You can read the full article here.
June 2, 2009
Arkansas Telerehab and Medicaid Reimbursement
Here’s a great video story from last year about a telerehabilitation program going on in Little Rock Arkansas. This hospital has implemented a simple two-way video chat into a patient’s home. Here are the highlights:
- patient suffered a broken hip as the result of a fall
- audio/video link from a hospital into a patient’s home
- both physical and occupational therapists are interacting with the patient over the link
- the patient is very happy with the service
- the clinic administrators see tremendous potential for at-home rehab to be far more convenient for patients and financially competitive for hospitals
- other devices can be hooked up to the computer to be used with a telerehab system (our ReJoyce Telerehabilitation System is a great example)
Arkansas is one of a number states that leaves decisions regarding reimbursement of telemedicine programs, including telerehabilitation, up to the state Medicaid director. Take a look at this 2004 study regarding Medicaid telerehabilitation reimbursement throughout the United States.
May 1, 2009
New Hampshire Senate passes Telecare Bill
The N.H Senate has passed a bill requiring insurance companies to reimburse certain medical appointments whether they happen face-to-face or not.
“…This is vastly going to reduce the costs of health care and help with early detection,” said Sen. Debbie Reynolds, D-Plymouth. Telemedicine would help with early detection and “access to specialty care that would reduce the severity of diseases…”
Read the full article here.
April 23, 2009
Significant Savings with Telecare in Scotland
A recent evaluation report has shown that a telecare program in Scotland has delivered significant cost savings and is improving health and quality of life for users. The report shows that the telecare initiative, outfitting 7,902 people with telecare equipment, saved the healthcare system more than £11m in 2007 and 2008. Here is a link to the full report.
April 22, 2009
SCI Solutions Network
The SCI Solutions Network (a Canadian organization devoted to improving the lives of people living with SCI) has recently included a story about ReJoyce. Here’s an excerpt from the article:
“…Restored hand function,” says Dr. Arthur Prochazka, “is at the top of the wish-list of people with tetraplegia—and also many people who are partially paralyzed due to stroke and multiple sclerosis.” Even small improvements in hand function, says Prochazka, can have huge implications, such as becoming employable or being able to live more independently without full-time attendant care. Besides the obvious quality-of-life improvements for individuals who are able to regain some hand function, there’s also potentially significant cost savings for Canada’s health and employment insurance programs…”
“…The solution, reasoned Prochazka, was to somehow allow the participant to perform the regimen in the comfort of their own home. And that’s exactly what he and a dedicated team of young scientists, therapists and engineers have achieved with the ReJoyce—a unique system that combines FES with in-home tele-rehabilitation (or teletherapy)….”
You can see the full article here.
April 17, 2009
Online Care and the Reduction of Health Care Costs
A study released in September, 2008 suggests that online health care services may reduce the cost of employer-sponsored health plans. The study suggests that savings could lie between $3.36 and $6.95 per member, per month.
Other studies, like this one and this one, have also demonstrated that telehomecare could lower the overall cost of healthcare significantly.